Confessions of a Board Game Geek

by Sarah on January 18, 2010 · 18 comments

In addition to reading and writing, one of my geekier interests is board games. I’m particularly fond of games of strategy, particularly those which are referred to as “German-style” games.

I’ve enjoyed board games since I was a child. My mother was not as keen on them as I was, and I often spent many a happy hour playing against myself! The great advantage to this was that I always won. However, it’s much more fun to play against a real person rather than my alter ego.

Here a few of my favourites. Most of those listed can be played as of two players, which is an important consideration for me when purchasing as I usually play against my husband. The few games we own which require a minimum of three players tend to gather dust unless we can persuade a hapless guest to play with us.

DOMINION (2-4 players)


This is my latest obsession. It’s not actually a board game, but a card game. The basic premise is that each player is a poor landowner during the Middle Ages. Everyone starts the game with a little money and a bit of land. The aim of the game is to build up your territory by virtue of acquiring land and enriching it with various institutions.

Dominion has three sorts of cards. There are money cards, action cards, and land cards. The money and the land cards are always the same. Each Dominion set comes equipped with 24 types of action cards, and each game requires the use of 10. By using different combinations of of action cards, it’s possible to vary the game each time it’s played.

The cards are beautifully illustrated and the instructions on the various action cards make for an enjoyable and varied game. For more possible action card combinations, the two add-on Dominion games can be used. They are Dominion: Intrigue and Dominion: Seaside. Here’s a picture of some of the cards. I couldn’t find a photo of the English version, so these are in German. From left to right: Village (Action); Moneylender (Action); Province (Land); Thief (Action); Gold (Money – yeah, real surprise!).

Here’s a photo of the card layout for a game. The 10 action cards are of varying value and they are grouped accordingly. This particular set of 10 action cards also calls for the use of curse cards which are worth minus 1 point at the end of the game, plus a trash can.

CARCASSONNE (2-5 players)


Carcassonne is another game set in the Middle Ages. The game consists of a score board, wooden playing figures and a selection of cardboard tiles. Each player in turn takes a tile from the pile and connects it to the existing collection of tiles on the table. The tiles build cities, roads, monasteries and farmland. Players who claim and complete cities, roads and monasteries are awarded points. Players also claim sections of farmland which are worth points at the end of the game. The winner is the person who amasses the most points.

To be successful at the original version of the game relies on a mixture of luck and strategy. There are several interesting expansions available for Carcassonne. These make the game more complex and more reliant on strategic planning than on luck.

THURN UND TAXIS (2-4 players)


This is yet another historical game. Anyone noticing a theme here? :D It’s set either in the mid-18th Century or the beginning of the 19th Century. (The box mentions the mid-18th Century but the clothes worn by the people on the playing cards remind me more of early 19th Century fashion).

At any rate, the game is based on the evolution of the postal network in Europe. The original postal service was pioneered by the wealthy German family of Thurn und Taxis. The game’s board shows a network of postal routes combining various cities in the countries we now refer to as Germany, Switzerland, Austria and Poland. The aim of the game is for each player to establish a maximum of five postal routes of varying length. Upon completing the individual routes, the players can claim points by placing their figures in cities and receiving point tokens for having, say, a presence in every city in Bavaria, or a piece in every country represented on the map.

Thurn und Taxis relies more on strategy than on luck, but it is not a terribly complex game. It is, however, a lot of fun to play, particularly when you’re not in the mood for a complicated game which requires a lot of concentration.

TICKET TO RIDE (2-5 players)


This game has a similar concept to Thurn und Taxis but it is set in the USA and Canada around 1900. There are various editions of the game in which the action takes place in other locations such as Europe, Scandanavia and Germany. There’s apparently also an edition which takes place in Switzerland, but our version is the original North American one, albeit in German.

The aim of the game is to visit as many cities as possible by train. Each player receives 45 train carriages and 2-3 route cards. A player may choose to complete all 3 routes, or return 1 and complete 2. This decision is based on the length of the respective routes and whether or not a player can realistically hope to complete them using their allotted 45 carriages.

The cities on the map are linked by coloured stretches of railroad. Some stretches allow up to two players to occupy them in a game with more than three players. Otherwise, each stretch of railroad can only be claimed by a single player. This makes it difficult for their opponents as they are frequently obliged to travel a circuitous route in order to reach their destination.

Here’s a photo of the board at the start of a game:

And at the end:

Ticket to Ride is extremely easy to learn and a lot of fun to play. While it is a mix of luck and strategy, it doesn’t require a lot of concentration and is ideal for an evening when you’re tired.

THE SETTLERS OF CATAN (3-5 players)


This is one of my favourite games, particularly when played with the Cities and Knights expansion. Unfortunately, it requires a minimum of three players, so I rarely get a chance to play it.

It is another historical game based on settlers in a new land. They fight for survival and enrich their land with a variety of raw materials such as iron, corn, and wood.

PUERTO RICO (3-5 players)


Like The Settlers of Catan, Puerto Rico requires a minimum of three players. It is has similar premise to Settlers but it is more complex and requires more strategic planning.

SCRABBLE (2+ players)


I don’t think this game requires any introduction! I like crosswords and I’m a fan of Scrabble.

Do you like board games/card games? Which ones are your favourites?

{ 18 comments }

Pearl January 18, 2010 at 13:20

Oooh hubby and I love board games too! We don’t have much time for them with our hobbies, work and social life but we always make time for them during vacations. Carcasonne is our favorite. We’ve got all the expansions, I gifted hubby the latest one here for Xmas and we’re taking Carcasonne with us on vacation coming February!

Of the other games we only have Scrabble but I have seen the others too and we’ve played the Settlers of Catan with friends who have the game.

It’s great to see that in this day and age of electronic gadgets and games (hubby works in the videogame industry so I shouldn’t complain too much) there are still game board geeks out there :D

SusiSunshine January 18, 2010 at 13:29

I found another junkie! YAY!!! I love these games. I can’t get enough of them.
I have the European edition of Ticket to Ride. It has a few additions like tunnels and train stations but the fun is the same!
Love your post and can totally relate to you!
And why is it called German-style? Anyone knows?

Sarah January 18, 2010 at 13:37

@Pearl: Yay! I am not alone in my addiction!
We have several of the Carcassonne expansions but we’re still missing a couple.

@SusiSunshine: I debated which edition of Ticket to Ride to buy, but decided on the original version. I figured it would refresh my hazy knowledge of North American geography!

The term “German-style game” is new for me, too. A friend mentioned it to me recently. Here’s the Wikipedia entry: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German-style_board_game

Leontine January 18, 2010 at 16:36

My family loves to play board games and many a sunday in my teenage years was spent around the table. I haven’t heard of any of your board games, I guess we were more the family to play monopoly, scrabble, games where we had to draw a word/saying, had to read lips, answers questions and so on. We also had a box of a dozen typical dutch board games etc. I don’t play frequently but with family or with friends I love to play, it is a great way to have fun :D

Andrea January 18, 2010 at 18:20

Have joined a meetup.com group that plays board games once or twice a week and have learned a bunch of obscure games lately such as Ra, Reef Attack and For Sale. Wouldn’t necessarily recommend the first two, but For Sale is a nice card game for a group, maybe once the kids get older.

My all time faves are Carcassonne, Catan, and Thurn & Taxis. I’ve just discovered Dominion through this group and am hooked too!

Metro is another good one, but though it can be played with 2-6 people, it is best for 3-6.

For Christmas I received Alhambra. Do you have this one Sarah? I played it once with Peter and lost horribly. Usually these games are better for me the second time around once I have a sense of how the game goes. I haven’t played it since I’ve received it for Xmas though.

Ticket to Ride I keep hearing about and need to try out. Puerto Rico is one I’ve heard is good, but have not heard much otherwise about it. And I’m miserable at Scrabble.

Boardgames are best for me in the winter when it is all cozy!

Sarah January 18, 2010 at 18:49

@Leontine: Board games are great fun. They’re also a good way to spend time with people and actually interact with them as opposed to sitting down and watching a film in silence.

@Andrea: He! You’re the person who got me hooked on Thurn & Taxis!

Are you sure you haven’t played Ticket to Ride? It’s called Zug um Zug in German. I know I spoke to someone recently who had it.

I know Alhambra. A certain person has a birthday soon… :D

Andrea January 18, 2010 at 19:25

We’re going to have to get Catan out when I come to visit next since we’ll have 3 people. Not being able to play with 2 people is the worst part of that game.

Nope, never did play Zug um Zug – it wasn’t me. But all this talk about it is making me anxious to try it out. You won’t believe how expensive these Eurogames are here! Glad I shipped some of them back when I moved, but wish I would have gotten more.

Sarah January 18, 2010 at 19:32

@Andrea: Seriously? Amazon.de has all the games on sale at the moment. For one like Dominion, the language is important, so you wouldn’t be able to play the German version with people who didn’t speak it. The only part of Ticket to Ride/Zug um Zug which is in German is the rule book. If you want to order any for the next time you’re over, have them shipped to my address.

Trish January 18, 2010 at 20:20

I’ve been in ‘Dominion’ withdrawal since Christmas, can’t wait to play it again on my next visit. At some stage I’ll have to get the English-language version so I’ll know what the cards say without needing a translator. Have heard of ‘Ticket to Ride’ and would like to try it. Love ‘Scrabble’. Hate ‘Monopoly’. Was addicted to ‘Trivial Pursuit’ for a long time but haven’t played it in ages.

Keira Soleore January 19, 2010 at 03:33

Great!! Here’s the board game post you were talking about. As you know, I’m a fan of Settlers of Catan. We also like Carcasonne and Scrabble. We also like Othello, Tikal, Continuo, Frog Juice, Guillotine, Frog Juice, Set, Lord of the Rings, Tuebingen, Word Trek, and Sweep (uses normal playing cards). For group games, we like Apples to Apples and Bohanza.

I’d love to try THURN UND TAXIS and TICKET TO RIDE.

Sarah January 19, 2010 at 13:28

@Trish: Ha! We’ll have to play when you’re here in April. I think you’ll like Ticket to Ride.

@Keira Soleore: Wow! Great list! I haven’t heard of several of those games. I must look them up. Thank you. :D

Andrea January 19, 2010 at 15:50

Funny, I just ordered Bohnanza last night on Ebay!

Tumperkin January 19, 2010 at 21:40

I RULE at Scrabble (much to my husband’s disgust). He kills me at Monopoly. I’ve not heard of most of these though.

Sarah January 20, 2010 at 13:57

@Andrea: Let me know what you think of it.

@Tumperkin: I haven’t played Monopoly in years. I love Scrabble but I haven’t played recently. That’s something I must remedy.

SonomaLass January 21, 2010 at 23:34

We are hardcore gamers at my house. Ticket to Ride is a favorite, and we like the various Catan games. Most popular of those here is Starfarers; it’s the first one for which we got the 5 & 6 player expansion, because both my sons play and bring friends. We also like Civilization (both versions, but I prefer the old Avalon Hill), Age of Renaissance, History of the World, Twilight Imperium, Merchant of Venus, and all the Empire Builder train games (especially Iron Dragon).

We also like some less intense games for shorter play, including Apples to Apples, Cranium and Quelf — hilarious! Card games include the Munchkin games, Oh Hell, and recently Quiddler and In Limbo.

I got Robo-Rally for Christmas, which I’ve wanted for a while, but there are cards missing so we can’t play it yet. But the all-time favorite game at our house is Kingmaker. Hands down, no question.

It’s so much fun reading about what other people play!

Sarah January 22, 2010 at 09:22

@SonomaLass: Another fan! Thanks for your list of games. There are several I’d never heard of before.

heidenkind January 23, 2010 at 23:31

I never played a lot of board games, because I was an only child. I do really like to play Clue. Life and Monopoly always seem to drag on forever to me. Sorry’s okay.

Scrabble is only entertaining for me if I can convince the other players that the words I make up are real words. :D

Keira Soleore January 24, 2010 at 05:55

Sarah, in the interest of completeness, here’s a recent blog post from author Donna MacMeans on the board games they play: http://romancebandits.blogspot.com/2010/01/games-we-play.html

Previous post:

Next post: